01438 741177         thewinesociety.com

Weekend drinking thread [9-11 November 2018]


#1

Here goes. Pouring with rain and very windy outside.


#2

Wet and windy down on the south coast too. This with lamb rogan josh curry, amazingly a recommended wine match on TWS website I noticed once I got it out


#3

Musar 2011.

Rather atypical, light, savoury, delicious.


#4

Presumably the atypical bit is the ‘light’?


#5

Yes but some vintages have a distinctive nose/taste which is attenuated here. Still unmistakably Musar.


#6


Just put this in the decanter to go with a dark looking beef stew. It’s almost black in colour, strongly scented with liquorice and leather. Can’t wait for later.


#7

Is this the stew? :wink: …bit worried about the scent of leather if it is…


#8

Ha ha… as long as the beef ain’t like leather.


#9

Oooh! let us know what you think of the Pittnauer, @Ludlow_Steve! I had a couple of his other wines, the most memorable of which was his ‘Velvet’ - a blend of Zweigelt, Blaufränkisch and a touch of Merlot. It was lovely, juicy and a little spicy. He does a really lovely Zweigelt rosé as well!


#10

Well, like I said the other day, I absolutely had to try this, The Polariser, the wine that repels as much as it attracts. A Trump, a Sanders, a Le Pen, a Mélenchon, a Johnson, a Corb…okay, you get my drift.

Right then. Lovely pale colour - you can actually tilt the glass and read a magazine through it, I’ve just tried. Austere - yes - but fragrant, with a sour cherry / cranberry / rhubarb sharpness to it. Nothing green here, nice and ripe in its own context, but still very tart on the palate, as expected. And there’s still that distant whiff of Mother Nature that good pinot does best.

I’m in two minds as to whether it’s worth a tenner, but I’m tending towards yes, as long as you know what you’re letting yourself in for. I completely understand where Toby The Buyer is coming from, saying that for Burgundy, in respect of price/quality, this wine is “at the limit of what is possible”.

But I think this would just about hold its own against other medium-bodied fragrant reds from elsewhere at this price point, albeit at the more marginal end of the ripeness spectrum. And I’ve just noticed that I’m happily nosing the empty glass, which is always a good sign in my book.

Anyone else tried it?

tl;dr - it’s good, honestly, but make sure you like this style of red first, otherwise it’ll be a shocker.


#11

Given the review earlier this week from @Inbar - intrigue has made me choose this for our squash risotto tonight

Also given the review, this is our backup…!


#12

IMHO, this a seriously good wine. Sometimes reds can hit you between the eyes (making them water), but this is smooth. It is Dave Brubeck, Jacques Loussier, or pastoral Debussy. It gently caresses the senses, leaving a pleasant afterthought.


#13

This somehow got opened to be enjoyed over the weekend.

Will see how it develops over the weekend… ought to now make some creamy chicken dish, too. Small glass today to be smelled and sipped over a movie. First impression on the nose is fat juicy pears, somewhat restrained but unputdownable; on the palate is distinctly nutty at this point. (I promise you I just read the Julia Harding review after I wrote this…)


#14

Week off next week, great to knock off early and have this with steak and chips

Had a mourvedre funk so gave it a good slosh in the decanter. Think it probably needs more time, quite heavy and dark smoky fruit but great with the steak. Good value.


#15

Home alone this eve, so just opened this to accompany a fillet steak:


#16

I think I might have mentioned this one before

If not here then elsewhere. It’s alarmingly easy to drink. Just having a glass (or two) with fish cakes and salad and after a quick top-up I notice that the bottle is nearly gone. Odd! But lucky I have more!


#17

Oh yes.


#18

Big cherry nose. Lovely Pinot colour. Deep fruit. Structured and refined and long. Beautiful. Glad I’ve got 4 more bottles.

I wonder how it will age? Not acidic at all so may struggle.

Edit. Actually I misread the low acidity, it has some, masked very well by the deep fruit and structure.


#19

This, with grilled sole, stir fried veg with ginger, lemongrass and chilli and Thai rice. Hit the spot. The Petit Chablis (with more fruit and oomph) of the Kumeu range.


#20

Doesn’t sound like it will get much of a chance!